Suggestions by @zacharyoxford
14,069 suggestions
Robert Englund
as Nightmare in Who could play Nightmare for marvel
Willem Dafoe
as Nightmare in Who could play Nightmare for marvel
Cillian Murphy
as Nightmare in Who could play Nightmare for marvel
Michael Fassbender
as Nightmare in Who could play Nightmare for marvel
Bill Skarsgård
as Nightmare in Who could play Nightmare for marvel
Adam Driver
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Sir Ben Kingsley
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Tim Curry
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Giancarlo Esposito
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Gary Oldman
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Jeremy Irons
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Crispin Glover
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Johnny Depp
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Jim Carrey
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Cillian Murphy
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Matthew McConaughey
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Joaquin Phoenix
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Andy Serkis
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel
Ralph Fiennes
as Mephisto in Who could play Mephisto in marvel