Suggestions by @willsheffield

Seann William Scott

as Green Lantern in James Gunn DCU

John Krasinski

as Green Lantern in James Gunn DCU

Riley Keough

as Anna Marie in Marvel Studios Mutants

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Silver Sablinova in Spider-Man

Guy Branum

as Wilson Fisk in Spider-Man

Madelaine Petsch

as Batgirl in New DCU

Chris Lowell

as Green Lantern in New DCU

Mark Wahlberg

as Green Lantern in New DCU

Luke Macfarlane

as Batman in New DCU

Daniel Dae Kim

as Batman in New DCU

Jake McDorman

as Batman in New DCU

Sebastian Stan

as Batman in New DCU

Charles Melton

as Dick Grayson in New DCU

Danny McBride

as Guy Gardner in New DCU

Andrea Martin

as Edna Mode in The Incredibles

Jimmy Bellinger

as IncrediBoy / Syndrome in The Incredibles

Zoey Deutch

as Elastigirl in The Incredibles

Riley Keough

as Rogue in Ultimate Universe (Marvel)

Hannah Simone

as Thalia Al Ghul in New DCU

Patton Oswalt

as Toyman in New DCU