Suggestions by @visno

Sox

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Heathcliff

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Thomas O'Malley (The Aristocats)

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Duchess (The Aristocats)

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Garfield

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Salem Saberhagen

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Jiji

as Cat in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Timothy Olyphant

as Jim Raynor in StarCraft (Live Action)

Dean Winters

as Aaron Paul in Actors who should play siblings.

Steve Harvey

as Pycelle in The WORST Game of Thrones

Sharktopus

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Jabberjaw

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Don Lino (Shark Tale)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Jab (Street Sharks)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Streex (Street Sharks)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Big Slammu (Street Sharks)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Ripster (Street Sharks)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Bruce (Finding Nemo)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Bruce (Jaws)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

King Shark (Nanaue)

as Shark in Sorting Fictional characters by Species