Suggestions by @user_26273
12,275 suggestions
Laughing Jack
as Best Creepypasta/Internet Horror in Best & Worst of Horror
Jeff the Killer
as Best Creepypasta/Internet Horror in Best & Worst of Horror
The Rake
as Best Creepypasta/Internet Horror in Best & Worst of Horror
Slender Man
as Best Creepypasta/Internet Horror in Best & Worst of Horror
The Man in the Suit
as Was Once a Man in Sort by Tropes
Lucifer Morningstar (Hazbin Hotel)
as Tiny Guy, Huge Girl in Sort by Tropes
Green Goblin (TSSM)
as Practically Joker in Sort by Tropes
Alastor the Radio Demon
as Perpetual Smiler in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Painful Transformation in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Outliving One's Offspring in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Not Quite Dead in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as No Name Given in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Loss of Identity in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Haunted Technology in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as A God Am I in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Fictionalized People in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Drunk on the Dark Side in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Demon of Human Origin in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Dark And Troubled Past in Sort by Tropes
The Man in the Suit
as Crusading Widow in Sort by Tropes