Suggestions by @trip_tank_69
113 suggestions
Natalie Dormer
as Hypodermic Sally in American Horror Story Recast
Nicholas Hoult
as Dr. Oliver Thredson in American Horror Story Recast
Joe Keery
as Kyle Spencer in American Horror Story Recast
Drew Barrymore
as Vivien Harmon in American Horror Story Recast
Kate Siegel
as Delphine LaLurie in American Horror Story Recast
Emma Thompson
as Myrtle Snow in American Horror Story Recast
Colton Haynes
as Mr. Malcolm Gallant in American Horror Story Recast
Josh Holloway
as William Van Henderson/ Elias Cunningham in American Horror Story Recast
Tobias Menzies
as Edward Mordrake in American Horror Story Recast
Dakota Fanning
as Misty Day in American Horror Story Recast
Lupita Nyong'o
as Marie Laveau in American Horror Story Recast
Shawnee Smith
as Wilhemina Venable in American Horror Story Recast
Chase Stokes
as Tate Langdon in American Horror Story Recast
Susan Sarandon
as Sister Jude Martin in American Horror Story Recast
Lucy Liu
as Shachath in American Horror Story Recast
Lily Cole
as Sister Mary Eunice McKee in American Horror Story Recast
Amanda Seyfried
as Sister Mary Eunice McKee in American Horror Story Recast
Lena Headey
as Fiona Goode in American Horror Story Recast
Maude Apatow
as Violet Harmon in American Horror Story Recast
Olivia DeJonge
as Zoe Benson in American Horror Story Recast