Suggestions by @tracygjackson2011

Patricia Clarkson

as Valerie Lewton in Final Destination (2000)

Irma P. Hall

as Martha in Jennifer (1998)

Chris Klein

as Superman in Smallville (2000s feature film)

Sara Paxton

as Frankie "The Beak" Holt in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Leah Pipes

as Frieda DeLois in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Michael Bay

as Director in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Drake

as Marty Liam Greg in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Shaun Sipos

as Todd Bourne in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Hunter Parrish

as Ross Gogan in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Tom Hern

as Mark Blake in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Ryan Hansen

as Julian McDermitt in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Taylor Kitsch

as Colin Wilson in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Amanda Crew

as Georgina Dawson in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Penn Badgley

as Ron Wilson in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Jesse Moss

as Fred Jason in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Scott Foley

as Coach Collins in Carey (Carrie Genderswap 2006)

Kirsten Dunst

as Kayla in Thirteen (1993)

Riley Smith

as Tommy in Jonathan (Jennifer 1998 Genderswap)

David Rees Snell

as Ben in Jonathan (Jennifer 1998 Genderswap)

Maggie Lawson

as Nancy in Jennifer (1998)