Suggestions by @tomzillawash3r3
178,116 suggestions
Cate Blanchett
as Galadriel in Muppet of the Rings
Beaker
as Isildur in Muppet of the Rings
Sean Bean
as Boromir in Muppet of the Rings
David Wenham
as Faramir in Muppet of the Rings
Pepé the King Prawn
as Theoden in Muppet of the Rings
Miss Piggy
as Eowyn in Muppet of the Rings
Liv Tyler
as Arwen in Muppet of the Rings
Dr. Bunsen Honeydew
as Elrond in Muppet of the Rings
Pops
as Bilbo Baggins in Muppet of the Rings
Sam the Eagle
as Saruman in Muppet of the Rings
Rizzo the Rat
as Pippin in Muppet of the Rings
Fernando González 'Gonzo'
as Merry in Muppet of the Rings
Fozzie Bear
as Gimli in Muppet of the Rings
Orlando Bloom
as Legolas in Muppet of the Rings
Kermit the Frog
as Aragorn in Muppet of the Rings
Big Bird
as Bilbo Baggins in Muppet of the Rings
Ian McKellen
as Gandalf in Muppet of the Rings
Bean Bunny
as Samwise Gamgee in Muppet of the Rings
Elijah Wood
as Frodo Baggins in Muppet of the Rings
Hercules (1997 film)
as Las Vegas looks like Greece in Hercules in Nostalgia Critic Muck-Ups