Suggestions by @timemachine

Drew Barrymore

as Alison DiLaurentis in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Lucy Liu

as Mona Vanderwaal in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Brandy Norwood

as Emily Fields in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Jennifer Love Hewitt

as Spencer Hastings/Alex Drake in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Denise Richards

as Hanna Marin in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Liv Tyler

as Aria Montgomery in Pretty Little Liars ('90s) (ghoulgirlelle's version)

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Dice Corleone in Sam & Cat ('90s)

Ashton Kutcher

as Goomer in Sam & Cat ('90s)

Julia Stiles

as Sam Puckett in Sam & Cat ('90s)

Brittany Murphy

as Cat Valentine in Sam & Cat ('90s)

Eliza Dushku

as Dana Cruz in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Nicole Bristow in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Rachael Leigh Cook

as Quinn Pensky in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Andrew Keegan

as Logan Reese in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Kristin Kreuk

as Lola Martinez in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Kenan Thompson

as Michael Barret in Zoey 101 ('90s)

James Van Der Beek

as Chase Matthews in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Haley Joel Osment

as Dustin Brooks in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Britney Spears

as Zoey Brooks in Zoey 101 ('90s)

Joey Lawrence

as Theo Raeken in Teen Wolf ('90s)