Suggestions by @timemachine
8,238 suggestions
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
as Tyler in Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween (1998)
James Marsden
as Blaine Anderson in Glee ('90s)
Seth Green
as Artie Abrams in Glee ('90s)
Neil Patrick Harris
as Kurt Hummel in Glee ('90s)
Jay Hernandez
as Noah Puckerman in Glee ('90s)
Brittany Murphy
as Brittany S. Pierce in Glee ('90s)
Alicia Silverstone
as Quinn Fabray in Glee ('90s)
John Travolta
as Will Schuester in Glee ('90s)
Countess Vaughn
as Mercedes Jones in Glee ('90s)
Jennifer Lopez
as Santana Lopez in Glee ('90s)
Jared Leto
as Finn Hudson in Glee ('90s)
Idina Menzel
as Rachel Berry in Glee ('90s)
Matthew Lillard
as Scott Pocket in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Melissa Joan Hart
as Jessica Betts in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Emaline Addario in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Jason Weaver
as Cedric in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Brandon Hammond
as Luke O'Neil in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Devon Sawa
as Oliver Schermerhorn in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Heather Matarazzo
as Leslie in Everything Sucks! (1998)
Harsh Mayar
as Ravi Ross in Jessie ('90s)