Suggestions by @timemachine
8,238 suggestions
Jennifer Love Hewitt
as Sue Snell in What Characters Do You Want to See Jennifer Love Hewitt Play in the '90s
Katie Cassidy
as Judy in What Characters Do You Want to See Katie Cassidy Play in the 2000s
Katie Cassidy
as Sarah Quinn in What Characters Do You Want to See Katie Cassidy Play in the 2000s
Katie Cassidy
as Taylor in What Characters Do You Want to See Katie Cassidy Play in the 2000s
Lacey Chabert
as Heather Duke in What Characters Do You Want to See Lacey Chabert Play in the 2000s
Robert De Niro
as Justin Foley in 13 Reasons Why (1967)
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Sarah Quinn in What Characters Do You Want to See Sarah Michelle Gellar Play in the '90s
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Taylor in What Characters Do You Want to See Sarah Michelle Gellar Play in the '90s
Hilary Duff
as Sarah Quinn in What Characters Do You Want to See Hilary Duff Play in the 2000s
Hilary Duff
as Taylor in What Characters Do You Want to See Hilary Duff Play in the 2000s
Sara Paxton
as Sarah Quinn in What Characters Do You Want to See Sara Paxton Play in the 2000s
Sara Paxton
as Taylor in What Characters Do You Want to See Sara Paxton Play in the 2000s
Lacey Chabert
as Hannah Stine/Fairchild in What Characters Do You Want to See Lacey Chabert Play in the 2000s
Lacey Chabert
as Sue Snell in What Characters Do You Want to See Lacey Chabert Play in the 2000s
Katie Cassidy
as Chris Hargensen in What Characters Do You Want to See Katie Cassidy Play in the 2000s
Molly Ringwald
as Anna Coleman in What Characters Do You Want to See Molly Ringwald in the '80s
Molly Ringwald
as Cady Heron in What Characters Do You Want to See Molly Ringwald in the '80s
Molly Ringwald
as Vickie in What Characters Do You Want to See Molly Ringwald in the '80s
Sally Field
as Gretchen Weiners in What Characters Do You Want to See Sally Field Play in the '60s
Sally Field
as Bertha in What Characters Do You Want to See Sally Field Play in the '60s