Suggestions by @timemachine
8,238 suggestions
Keanu Reeves
as Nick Castle in The Fog (1985)
Miranda Cosgrove
as Gwen in Dexter's Laboratory (2000s live-action movie)
Emily Osment
as Becky in Dexter's Laboratory (2000s live-action movie)
Hayley Mills
as Mena Suvari in '90s Actors in the '60s
Diana Ross
as Gabrielle Union in '90s Actors in the '60s
Sally Field
as Neve Campbell in '90s Actors in the '60s
Cher
as Liv Tyler in '90s Actors in the '60s
Sally Field
as Jennifer Love Hewitt in '90s Actors in the '60s
Candice Bergen
as Melissa Joan Hart in '90s Actors in the '60s
Donna Mills
as Christine Taylor in '90s Actors in the '60s
Nancy Sinatra
as Marley Shelton in '90s Actors in the '60s
Sally Field
as Rachael Leigh Cook in '90s Actors in the '60s
Joan Van Ark
as Julia Stiles in '90s Actors in the '60s
Twiggy
as Larisa Oleynik in '90s Actors in the '60s
Sharon Tate
as Sarah Michelle Gellar in '90s Actors in the '60s
Nichelle Nichols
as Stacey Dash in '90s Actors in the '60s
Ann-Margret
as Alicia Silverstone in '90s Actors in the '60s
Robert De Niro
as '60s in Which Actor Should've Played Nick Castle in Various Decades
Milo Manheim
as 2020s in Which Actor Should've Played Nick Castle in Various Decades
Dylan Minnette
as 2010s in Which Actor Should've Played Nick Castle in Various Decades