Suggestions by @timemachine

Renee Murphy

as Cheryl in The Fury (1988)

Mia Sara

as Gillian Bellaver in The Fury (1988)

Lisa Pelikan

as Valentina Furi in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Michael Jackson

as Rory Carmichael in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Linda Purl

as Isabel Armstrong in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Debbie Allen

as Layla Fletcher in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Debbie Allen

as Ava Banji in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Irene Cara

as Sophia Mendoza in Unicorn Academy ('70s live action)

Laura Marano

as Laney Boggs in What Characters Do You Want to See Laura Marano Play in the 2010s

Laura Marano

as Sue Snell in What Characters Do You Want to See Laura Marano Play in the 2010s

Laura Marano

as Lex in What Characters Do You Want to See Laura Marano Play in the 2010s

Millie Bobby Brown

as 2020s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Hailee Steinfeld

as 2010s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Anne Hathaway

as 2000s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Neve Campbell

as '90s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Winona Ryder

as '80s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Linda Blair

as '70s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Sally Field

as '60s in Which Actress Should've Played Gillian Bellaver in Various Decades?

Helen Slater

as Carrie White in What Characters Do You Want to See Helen Slater Play in the '80s

Helen Slater

as Sarah Quinn in What Characters Do You Want to See Helen Slater Play in the '80s