Suggestions by @themegacaster

Matthew Patrick Davis

as Gill Man in Monster Squad

Olga Kurylenko

as The Bride in Monster Squad

Viggo Mortensen

as Dracula in Monster Squad

Jon Hamm

as Solomon Grundy in Monster Squad

Robert Pattinson

as Tony Stark in Monster Squad

Emma Corrin

as Enchantress in Monster Squad

Charlie Cox

as Frankenstein in Monster Squad

Clint Eastwood

as Rick Flag Sr. in Monster Squad

Anthony Mackie

as Nick Fury Jr in Monster Squad

Barbara Eden

as Karin Grace in Monster Squad

Simon Pegg

as Ivo Robotnik in Monster Squad

Jack Black

as The Big Bad Wolf in Monster Squad

Ashley Walters

as Blade in Monster Squad

Mark Hamill

as G.I Robot in Monster Squad

David Dastmalchian

as Morbius The Living Vampire in Monster Squad

Tommy Lee Jones

as Nick Fury Sr. in Monster Squad

Paul King

as Director in Superman

Mjölnir

as “In The New Mexico Desert” in Superman

Lars Mikkelsen

as “In The New Mexico Desert” in Superman

Spoiler

as “In The New Mexico Desert” in Superman