Suggestions by @thatrandomgai

Heath Ledger

as Thor (actually played by Chris Hemsworth; 2001-2026) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Jeff Goldblum

as Bruce Banner/Hulk (actually played by Mark Ruffalo; 2002-2016) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Kyle MacLachlan

as Bruce Banner/Hulk (actually played by Edward Norton; 1998) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Tom Cruise

as Anthony Stark/Iron Man (actually played by Robert Downey Jr.; 1998-2009) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Pierce Brosnan

as Anthony Stark/Iron Man (actually played by Robert Downey Jr.; 1998-2009) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Kevin Costner

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by George Clooney; 1987) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Harrison Ford

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Val Kilmer; 1985) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Ray Liotta

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Val Kilmer; 1985) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Michael Keaton

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Val Kilmer; 1985) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

George Clooney

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Christian Bale; 1995-2002) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Val Kilmer

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Christian Bale; 1995-2002) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Brad Pitt

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Christian Bale; 1995-2002) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Michael J. Fox

as Peter Parker/Spider-Man (actually played by Tobey Maguire; 1992-1997, 2011) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Mel Gibson

as James Howlett/Logan/Wolverine (actually played by Hugh Jackman; 1990-2007, 2014) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Carl Weathers

as Eric Brooks/Blade (actually played by Wesley Snipes; 1988-1994, 2014) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Harrison Ford

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Michael Keaton; 1979-1982, 2012-2013) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Christopher Walken

as Bruce Wayne/Batman (actually played by Michael Keaton; 1979-1982, 2012-2013) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Robert Redford

as Clark Kent/Kal-El/Superman (actually played by Christopher Reeve; 1968-1977) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

John Gavin

as Clark Kent/Kal-El/Superman (actually played by Christopher Reeve; 1968-1977) in Marvel and DC movies and shows but 10 years earlier

Lili Reinhart

as Black Canary in James Gunn DCU