Suggestions by @super_wahrrior

Percival C. McLeach

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Tarzan (Disney)

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Gretel Grant-Gomez

as Hamsters in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Peter Pettigrew

as Rats in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Ron Weasley

as Rats in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Harry Potter

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Cedric the Sorcerer

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Maleficent (Sleeping Beauty character)

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Presto DiGiotagione

as Rabbits in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Sofia the First (character)

as Rabbits in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Mario (Nintendo Character)

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Fa Mulan

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Luigi (Nintendo Character)

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Ryder (PAW Patrol)

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Humpty Dumpty (Puss in Boots)

as Geese in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Rumplestilkin (Shrek)

as Geese in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Pa Grape

as Mules in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Jessie (Toy Story)

as Horses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Sheriff Woody Pride

as Horses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Prince Hans

as Horses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have