Suggestions by @super_wahrrior

King Boo

as Luigi in Sorting Fictional Characters by their Arch-enemy

Carnage (Cletus Kasady)

as Venom in Sorting Fictional Characters by their Arch-enemy

South Dakota

as Super Wahrrior in Places MyCast Users HAVE been to

Portland, Oregon

as Super Wahrrior in Places MyCast Users HAVE been to

Denver

as Super Wahrrior in Places MyCast Users HAVE been to

Sherlock Holmes (BBC)

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Sherman Peabody

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Mayor Humdinger

as Cats in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Superman (Clark Kent)

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Batman (Bruce Wayne)

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Scorpion (Mac Gargan)

as Bugs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Boa Hancock

as Snakes in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Princess Elise

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Floyd Eaglesan

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Marshmallow (Annoying Orange)

as Ponies in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Willy Wonka (Johnny Depp)

as Sheep in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Linda Gunderson

as Parrots in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Hiccup Horrendous Haddock III

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Kronk Pepikrankenitz

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Toph Beifong

as Exotic Pets in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have