Suggestions by @super_wahrrior

Chris Pratt

as Mario in Super Mario Bros

Mark Mitchell

as St. Nicholas in World History

Pat Fraley

as St. Nicholas in World History

Donovan Scott

as St. Nicholas in World History

Peter Jason

as St. Nicholas in World History

Patrick Bauchau

as St. Nicholas in World History

Pyotr Fyodorov

as St. Nicholas in World History

Abraham Benrubi

as St. Nicholas in World History

Robby Benson

as St. Nicholas in World History

Boman Irani

as St. Nicholas in World History

Peter Franzén

as St. Nicholas in World History

George Hamilton

as St. Nicholas in World History

Jeffery Tambor

as St. Nicholas in World History

Judd Nelson

as St. Nicholas in World History

James Earl Jones

as St. Nicholas in World History

Ken Hudson Campbell

as St. Nicholas in World History

James Cosmo

as St. Nicholas in World History

Brian Blessed

as St. Nicholas in World History

Tim Allen

as St. Nicholas in World History

Brian Blessed

as Charlie Daniels in World History