Suggestions by @siddarthsid

Scarlett Johansson

as Elastigirl in The Incredibles

Chris Evans

as Mr. Incredible in The Incredibles

Anthony Mackie

as Frozone in The Incredibles

Rainn Wilson

as The Underminer in The Incredibles

Nathan Lane

as Gilbert Huph in The Incredibles

Kathryn Hahn

as Evelyn Deavor in The Incredibles

Jason Bateman

as Winston Deavor in The Incredibles

Olivia Wilde

as Mirage in The Incredibles

Amanda Seyfried

as Mirage in The Incredibles

Jesse Plemons

as IncrediBoy / Syndrome in The Incredibles

Kiernan Shipka

as Violet Parr in The Incredibles

Dane DeHaan

as IncrediBoy / Syndrome in The Incredibles

Lio Tipton

as Voyd in The Incredibles

Brie Larson

as Voyd in The Incredibles

Jared Gilmore

as Tony Rydinger in The Incredibles

Laura Dern

as Edna Mode in The Incredibles

Aubrey Plaza

as Evelyn Deavor in The Incredibles

Anne Hathaway

as Evelyn Deavor in The Incredibles

Oscar Isaac

as Winston Deavor in The Incredibles

Chris Pine

as Winston Deavor in The Incredibles