Suggestions by @sarahlalbuquerque

Júlia (Jolie)

as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters Club if fictional characters made it

Elisa (Jolie)

as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters Club if fictional characters made it

Beth March

as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters Club if fictional characters made it

Estefânia "Fani" Castelino Belluz

as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters Club if fictional characters made it

Laura (Jolie)

as Mixed Race in Characters by heritage

Laura (Jolie)

as Black in Characters by heritage

Laura (Jolie)

as Brazilian in Characters by heritage

Laura (Jolie)

as Laura in Sorting Characters by Name

Laura (Jolie)

as Katani Summers in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Jessi Ramsey

as Katani Summers in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Rocky Blue

as Katani Summers in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Júlia (Jolie)

as Avery Madden in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Claudia Kishi

as Avery Madden in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Kitty Covey

as Avery Madden in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Olívia (Jolie)

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Dawn Schafer

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Rory Gilmore

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Dorothy Gale

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Rapunzel (Disney)

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it

Twilight Sparkle

as Charlotte Ramsey in Beacon Street Girls if fictional characters made it