Suggestions by @sadielover01

Catherine Hickland

as Chlöe Rice in 13 Reasons Why (70s)

Catherine Hickland

as Vanessa in Five Nights at Freddy's (1983)

Ahna Capri

as 60s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Kelli Presley in Various Decades?

Laurie Walters

as 70s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Jamie/Colette Hughes in Various Decades?

Laurie Walters

as Kat in 13 Reasons Why (70s)

Nicki Aycox

as 90s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Jamie/Colette Hughes in Various Decades?

Devon Aoki

as Ava Brucks in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2005)

Rainbow Harvest

as Hannah Baker in 13 Reasons Why (80s)

Marie-Alise Recasner

as Jessica Davis in 13 Reasons Why (80s)

Nicki Aycox

as 90s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Kelli Presley in Various Decades?

Blake Heron

as Larry Granger in Fear Street: Prom King (2005 Genderswap)

Lisa Bonet

as Josie McCoy in Riverdale (1980s)

Penelope Sudrow

as 80s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Jamie/Colette Hughes in Various Decades?