Suggestions by @s105042

Common

as Jax Briggs in Zack Snyder's Mortal Kombat (2011)

Josh Gad

as The Penguin in Ben Affleck's The Batman (2022)

Oscar Isaac

as The Riddler in Ben Affleck's The Batman (2022)

Jeremy Irons

as Alfred Pennyworth in Ben Affleck's The Batman (2022)

J.K. Simmons

as Lt. James Gordon in Ben Affleck's The Batman (2022)

Ben Affleck

as The Batman in Ben Affleck's The Batman (2022)

Michael Gough

as Alfred Pennyworth in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Pat Hingle

as Commissioner Gordon in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Michael Keaton

as Batman in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Helena Bonham Carter

as Poison Ivy in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Patrick Stewart

as Mr. Freeze in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Sylvester Stallone

as Mr. Freeze in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Batgirl in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Christina Ricci

as Batgirl in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Marlon Wayans

as Robin in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Edward Furlong

as Robin in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Danny Elfman

as Composer in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Tim Burton

as Director in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin (1997)

Brad Dourif

as Fred Stickley in Tim Burton's Batman Forever (1995)

Tim Burton

as Director in Tim Burton's Batman Forever (1995)