Suggestions by @rodgonzalez

Vin Diesel

as Bo Bandit in Smokey and the Bandit - (Reboot)

+1-2Score: -1

Timothy Olyphant

as Jack Skellington in The Nightmare Before Christmas

+1-3Score: -2

Tim Curry

as Jack Skellington in The Nightmare Before Christmas

+5-4Score: +1

Peter Cushing

as Judge Claude Frollo in The Hunchback of Notre Dame (Live Action)

+1-4Score: -3

Vincent Price

as Macbeth in Macbeth

+2-3Score: -1