Suggestions by @rockscar

Wyatt Russell

as The New Guy As Another Journalist in Peter & Mary Jane

Spoiler

as The New Guy As Another Journalist in Peter & Mary Jane

Ethan Cutkosky

as Young Peter in Peter & Mary Jane

Talia Ryder

as Young Mary Jane in Peter & Mary Jane

Cooper Hoffman

as Young Harry in Peter & Mary Jane

Charles Parnell

as Robbie Robertson in Peter & Mary Jane

Michael C. Hall

as Norman Osborn in Peter & Mary Jane

Ryan Gosling

as Matt Murdock in Peter & Mary Jane

Marvin Jones III

as Tombstone in Peter & Mary Jane

Kelvin Harrison Jr.

as Randy Robertson in Peter & Mary Jane

Ayo Edebiri

as Janice Lincoln in Peter & Mary Jane

Jack O'Connell

as Boomerang in Peter & Mary Jane

Gabriel Luna

as Scorpion in Peter & Mary Jane

Jon Hamm

as J. Jonah Jameson in Peter & Mary Jane

Sonoya Mizuno

as Lt. Yuri Watanabe in Peter & Mary Jane

David Krumholtz

as Dr. Otto Octavius in Peter & Mary Jane

David Dastmalchian

as Mysterio in Peter & Mary Jane

Glen Powell

as Flash Thompson in Peter & Mary Jane

André Holland

as Ben Urich in Peter & Mary Jane

Manny Jacinto

as Ned Leeds in Peter & Mary Jane