Suggestions by @robertcooper

Rob Rackstraw

as Bertram in Thomas & Friends

Craig Ferguson

as Duncan in Thomas & Friends

Matt Wilkinson

as Rusty in Thomas & Friends

Joaquin Phoenix

as Peter Sam in Thomas & Friends

Keith Wickham

as Sir Handel in Thomas & Friends

Ben Small

as Rheneas in Thomas & Friends

Idris Elba

as Skarloey in Thomas & Friends

Jason Lee

as Connor in Thomas & Friends

Emma Stone

as Caitlin in Thomas & Friends

Jules de Jongh

as Clarabel in Thomas & Friends

Teresa Gallagher

as Annie in Thomas & Friends

Keith Wickham

as Harvey The Crane in Thomas & Friends

Lucy Montgomery

as Carly The Crane in Thomas & Friends

Tina Fey

as Carly The Crane in Thomas & Friends

Rodger Bumpass

as Cranky The Crane in Thomas & Friends

Hugh Jackman

as Cranky The Crane in Thomas & Friends

Jules de Jongh

as Lady Hatt in Thomas & Friends

Keith Wickham

as Sir Topham Hatt in Thomas & Friends

Rachael Miller

as Rebecca The Yellow Tender Tank Engine in Thomas & Friends

Nikki Griffin

as Rebecca The Yellow Tender Tank Engine in Thomas & Friends