Suggestions by @pauldmckay
41 suggestions
Kevin Kline
as Treebeard in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Judi Dench
as Arwen in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jeff Goldblum
as Mouth of Sauron in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Shia LaBeouf
as Eomer in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Paul Giamatti
as Elrond in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Matt Berry
as Theoden in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Eric André
as Grima Wormtongue in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joey Diaz
as King of the Dead in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jay Baruchel
as Lurtz in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
David Spade
as Haldir of Lorien in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Owen Wilson
as Mouth of Sauron in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jonah Hill
as Grima Wormtongue in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Pauly Shore
as Isildur in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Conan O'Brien
as Treebeard in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Wayne Brady
as Sauron in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Timothy Olyphant
as All of the Oliphants in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Tom Kenny
as Witch-King of Angmar in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Zach Galifianakis
as Theoden in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Dave Franco
as Faramir in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
James Franco
as Boromir in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast