Suggestions by @parzivaljoker

Jessica Chastain

as Dr. Sarah Cooper in The Big Chill (2013)

Alexander Skarsgård

as Harold Cooper in The Big Chill (2013)

Ryan Gosling

as Nick Carlton in The Big Chill (2013)

Kyle Gallner

as Pyro in X2 (2013)

Sienna Miller

as Mystique in X2 (2013)

AnnaSophia Robb

as Rogue in X2 (2013)

Logan Lerman

as Iceman in X2 (2013)

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Nightcrawler in X2 (2013)

Ray Winstone

as William Stryker in X2 (2013)

Chris Pine

as Cyclops in X2 (2013)

Jessica Chastain

as Jean Grey in X2 (2013)

Naomie Harris

as Storm in X2 (2013)

Jeremy Irons

as Magneto in X2 (2013)

Tom Hardy

as Wolverine in X2 (2013)

Bill Nighy

as Professor Charles Xavier in X2 (2013)

Blake Lively

as "Rachel Dawes" in The Nolan Trilogy (2015 - 2022)

Lee Byung-hun

as Ra's Al Ghul in The Nolan Trilogy (2015 - 2022)

Robert Pattinson

as The Joker in The Nolan Trilogy (2015 - 2022)

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as The Joker in The Nolan Trilogy (2015 - 2022)

Brendan Gleeson

as Carmine Falcone in The Nolan Trilogy (2015 - 2022)