Suggestions by @paristhefilmgirl

Debbie Allen

as Heather Montgomery in John Tucker Must Die (1976)

Ami (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Lark Voorhies in Which characters should actors have played in the 90's?

Julie James

as Jennifer Love Hewitt in Characters actors have played or will play

Brynn (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Rachel McAdams in Which characters should actors have played in the 2000's?

Brynn (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Jennie Garth in Which characters should actors have played in the 90's?

Sienna (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Lisa Pelikan in Which characters should actors have played in the 70’s?

Roxy Richter

as E.G. Daily in Which characters should actors have played in the 80’s?

Zeke Baylor

as Ralph Carter in Which characters should actors have played in the 70’s?

Zeke Baylor

as High School Musical in Disney Sorting

Julie James

as Final Girl in Sort by Tropes

Alex Bell

as Final Girl in Sort by Tropes

Skye Rotter

as Final Girl in Sort by Tropes

Lilly (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Rachael Leigh Cook in Which characters should actors have played in the 90's?

Jane Villanueva

as Gina Rodriguez in Characters actors have played or will play

Tom Hanks

as Derek in My Super Psycho Sweet 16 (70’s)

Courtney Ramirez (My Super Sweet Psycho 16)

as Gina Rodriguez in Characters actors have played or will play

Sue Snell

as Lori Loughlin in Which characters should actors have played in the 80’s?

Liv McKenzie

as Nonconformist Dyed Hair in Sort by Tropes

Shelby Cummings

as Cybill Shepherd in Which characters should actors have played in the 70’s?

Robyn Lively

as Cindy Berman in Fear Street franchise (1991)