Suggestions by @optimistic_writer
11,166 suggestions
Tyler Hoechlin
as Savior in Supergirl (Season 5)
Tyler Posey
as Green Lantern in Supergirl (Season 5)
Katie McGrath
as Lena Luthor in Supergirl (Season 5)
Adrian Pasdar
as Morgan Edge in Supergirl (Season 5)
Dacre Montgomery
as Valor in Supergirl (Season 5)
Annie Wersching
as Superwoman in Supergirl (Season 5)
Madison Pettis
as Starlight in Supergirl (Season 5)
Mehcad Brooks
as Steel in Supergirl (Season 5)
Jeremy Jordan
as Winn Schott in Supergirl (Season 5)
Billy Magnussen
as Jimmy Olsen in Supergirl (Season 5)
Molly C. Quinn
as Supergirl/Power Girl in Supergirl (Season 5)
Renee Olstead
as Shayera Hol in Supergirl (Season 4)
Jared Padalecki
as Katar Hol in Supergirl (Season 4)
Dacre Montgomery
as Mon-El/Lar Gand in Supergirl (Season 4)
Adam Scott
as Pete Ross in Supergirl (Season 4)
Annie Wersching
as Lana Lang in Supergirl (Season 4)
Christopher Eccleston
as Doctor Occult in Supergirl (Season 4)
Jeremy Jordan
as Winn Schott in Supergirl (Season 4)
Billy Magnussen
as Jimmy Olsen in Supergirl (Season 4)
David Harewood
as Martian Manhunter in Supergirl (Season 4)