Suggestions by @optimistic_writer

Charles Cyphers

as Charles Cyphers in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Tom Atkins

as Dan Challis in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Donald Sutherland

as Seamus Cochran in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Steve Miner

as Steve Miner in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Tom Ellis

as Tom Ellis/Michael Myers in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Nick Castle

as Nick Castle in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Kyle Richards

as Kyle Richards in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Paul Rudd

as Paul Rudd in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Danielle Harris

as Danielle Harris in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Josh Hartnett

as Josh Hartnett in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Jamie Lee Curtis in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

John Carpenter

as Writer in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

John Carpenter

as Director in Halloween Returns: Season of the Witch II

Hugh Jackman

as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th Returns

Henry Thomas

as Will Fullman in Friday the 13th Returns

Josh Hutcherson

as Head Counselor Aaron in Friday the 13th Returns

Erin Moriarty

as Head Counselor Sabrina in Friday the 13th Returns

Ed Oxenbould

as Earl Carlson in Friday the 13th Returns

Michael Rainey Jr.

as Tony Ward in Friday the 13th Returns

Natalie Alyn Lind

as Tiffany Fitzgerald in Friday the 13th Returns