Suggestions by @oliviafranklin

Oscar (Shark Tale)

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Escargoon

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Max (The Secret Life of Pets)

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Mike Wazowski

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Fix-It Felix Jr.

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Sam-I-Am

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Odie (Garfield)

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Emperor Kuzco

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Barney Rubble

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Boo-Boo Bear

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Goofy

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Tigger

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Donkey (Shrek)

as Elliot in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Will Ferrell

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Steve Carell

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

John Krasinski

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Ryan Reynolds

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Jensen Ackles

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

Tom Hardy

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)

James McAvoy

as Boog in Shrek (Non Disney CGI Edition)