Suggestions by @noahpopejoy
2,120 suggestions
Ryan Gosling
as Luigi in Mario
Troy Baker
as The Joker in The Casagrandes & Justice League: The Revenge of The Joker
Jeremy Irons
as Alder Cobweb in Children of Voldemort
Nicholas Hoult
as Alder Cobweb in Children of Voldemort
Robert Pattinson
as Alder Cobweb in Children of Voldemort
Al Pacino
as Waluigi in Mario
Danny DeVito
as Wario in Mario
Natalie Portman
as Daisy in Mario
James Franco
as Luigi in Mario
Josh Brolin
as Bowser in Mario
Josh Brolin
as Bowser in Mario
Andy Serkis
as Toad in Mario
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Bowser in Mario
Kathryn Newton
as Peach in Mario
Tom Hanks
as Luigi in Mario
Johnny Depp
as Mario in Mario
Chris Pratt
as Dorkon in Nostalgia Critic: The Movie
Jeremy Jahns
as Jeremy Jahns in Nostalgia Critic: The Movie
Chris Stuckmann
as Chris Stuckmann in Nostalgia Critic: The Movie
Rob Walker
as Santa Christ in Nostalgia Critic: The Movie