Suggestions by @nitrogencake
4,137 suggestions
Nathan Lane
as Sam in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Nicolas Cage
as Aragorn in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Jack Black
as Sam in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Mel Brooks
as Sauron in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Dom DeLuise
as Gimli in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Peter MacNicol
as Gollum in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Carl Reiner
as Saruman in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Mel Brooks
as Writer in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Mel Brooks
as Director in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Bill Pullman
as Legolas in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Rowan Atkinson
as Gollum in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Mel Brooks
as Gandalf in Mel Brooks's The Lord of The Rings
Jack Black
as Danny Devito in Actors' Modern Counterparts
Patrick Stewart
as Middle-Earth in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Matt Smith
as Middle-Earth in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Hugh Laurie
as Middle-Earth in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Johnny Depp
as Middle-Earth in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Colin Farrell
as Middle-Earth in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Alfred Molina
as DC Extended Universe in Actors who should join certain big franchises
Bob Hoskins
as Randall Pepperidge in The Pink Panther Duology (1996-1999)