Suggestions by @ninox

Michael Rosenbaum

as Lex Luthor in Superman: Doomsday

Tom Welling

as Superman in Superman: Doomsday

Charles Martinet

as Toadsworth in Fox's Mario (2009)

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Princess Daisy in Fox's Mario (2009)

Kazumi Totaka

as Yoshi in Fox's Mario (2009)

Samantha Kelly

as Toad in Fox's Mario (2009)

Dave Bautista

as Donkey Kong in Fox's Mario (2009)

Josh Brolin

as Bowser in Fox's Mario (2009)

Andy Samberg

as Luigi in Fox's Mario (2009)

Alicia Silverstone

as Princess Peach in Fox's Mario (2009)

Dan Fogler

as Mario in Fox's Mario (2009)

Michaela Jill Murphy

as "A Group Of Time Travelers" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Natalie Portman

as "A Group Of Time Travelers" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as "A Group Of Time Travelers" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Spoiler

as "A Group Of Time Travelers" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Zach Tyler Eisen

as "Sonic and His Friends" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Rick Yune

as "Sonic and His Friends" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Terry Crews

as "Sonic and His Friends" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Kath Soucie

as "Sonic and His Friends" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)

Dakota Fanning

as "Sonic and His Friends" in Shadow The Hedgehog (2004)