Suggestions by @nihilus

Jared Padalecki

as The Question in The Question

Evan Peters

as The Question in The Question

Christian Bale

as The Question in The Question

Luke Evans

as The Question in The Question

Wes Bentley

as The Question in The Question

Dacre Montgomery

as The Question in The Question

Dylan O'Brien

as The Question in The Question

Andrew Garfield

as The Question in The Question

David Tennant

as The Question in The Question

Lee Pace

as The Question in The Question

Jeremy Allen White

as The Question in The Question

Diego Luna

as The Question in The Question

Sharlto Copley

as The Question in The Question

Michael Shannon

as The Question in The Question

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as The Question in The Question

Wyatt Russell

as The Question in The Question

Josh Hartnett

as The Question in The Question

Aaron Paul

as The Question in The Question

Richard Madden

as The Question in The Question

Benedict Cumberbatch

as The Question in The Question