Suggestions by @nathanbates

Keith William Richards

as Salvatore Maroni in Batman

Tom Hollander

as Mister Toad in Batman

Katy O'Brian

as The Huntress in Batman

Hugh Grant

as Mister Toad in Batman

Sonoya Mizuno

as Harley Quinn in Batman

Jodie Turner-Smith

as Catwoman in Batman

Harry Melling

as The Ventriloquist in Batman

Rachel Weisz

as Mr. Freeze in Batman

Abbey Lee Kershaw

as Harley Quinn in Batman

Jesse Plemons

as Two-Face in Batman

Evan Rachel Wood

as Batwoman in Batman

Jennifer Jason Leigh

as Leslie Thompkins in Batman

Adria Arjona

as Catwoman in Batman

Holt McCallany

as David Cain in Batman

Nicolas Cage

as Doctor Hurt in Batman

Vanessa Kirby

as The Phantasm in Batman

Mia Goth

as Lady Clay in Batman

Michael Stuhlbarg

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman

Steven Yeun

as Hush in Batman

Dave Bautista

as Clayface in Batman