Suggestions by @nathanbates
24,066 suggestions
John C. Reilly
as J. Wellington Wimpy in Popeye
Josh Brolin
as Bluto in Popeye
Joaquin Phoenix
as Popeye in Popeye
J.K. Simmons
as Poopdeck Pappy in Popeye
Javier Bardem
as Zeus in The Iliad
Tommy Flanagan
as Slade Wilson "Deathstroke" in The Batman
Charles Dance
as Professor James Moriarty in 221B Baker Street
Ralph Fiennes
as Sherlock Holmes in 221B Baker Street
Harvey Keitel
as J. Jonah Jameson in The Spectacular Spider-Man (1985)
Diane Lane
as Mary Jane Watson in The Spectacular Spider-Man (1985)
Scoot McNairy
as Stanley Uris in It: Chapter Two (Alternative Casting)
Evangeline Lilly
as Beverly Marsh in It: Chapter Two (Alternative Casting)
Gemma Arterton
as Sif in Thor
Mads Mikkelsen
as Odin in Thor
Alden Ehrenreich
as Leonardo DiCaprio in Leonardo DiCaprio Biopic
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Jack Nicholson in Leonardo DiCaprio Biopic
George Clooney
as Fast Eddie Felson in The Color of Money
Viggo Mortensen
as Chris in The Magnificent Seven
Michael Kenneth Williams
as Scar in The Lion King (human live action version)
Nick Castle
as Michael Myers in SAVAGE WORLD