Suggestions by @mr95

Steve Coulter

as Leonard King, a retired judge. in Shakespeare Unbound

Annalisa Cochrane

as Olivia Prince, a florist’s assistant. in Shakespeare Unbound

Kurt Yaeger

as Malcolm Black, a construction foreman. in Shakespeare Unbound

Genevieve O'Reilly

as Julia Martin, a nurse. in Shakespeare Unbound

Khiva Iskak

as Raymond King, the town’s police chief. in Wrestling With Destiny

Tony Dalton

as Roman Martin, a florist. in Shakespeare Unbound

Dashiell Messitt

as Samuel Black (Rosaline’s Son with Hamlet) in Shakespeare Unbound

Will Poulter

as Henry Prince (Rosaline’s Former Lover) in Shakespeare Unbound

Josh Radnor

as Richard King (True Villain) in Shakespeare Unbound

Caitríona Balfe

as Margaret Black (Mayor, Antagonist Turned Redeemed) in Shakespeare Unbound

Victoria Pedretti

as Rose Marie (Protagonist) in Shakespeare Unbound

Annalise Basso

as Rebecca “Becky” Sanders in Legacy of Magic

Kunle Afolayan

as Samuel “Sam” Okoye in Legacy of Magic

Jacob Romero Gibson

as Tyler Brooks in Legacy of Magic

Pooja Hegde

as Priya Patel in Legacy of Magic

Sam Riley

as Oliver Grant in Legacy of Magic

Shailyn Pierre-Dixon

as Jasmine “Jazz” Brooks in Legacy of Magic

Jon Cryer

as Henry “Hank” Disney in Legacy of Magic

Irene Choi

as Abigail “Abby” Lin in Legacy of Magic

Clinton Liberty

as Marcus Reed in Legacy of Magic