Suggestions by @moonlightbeast495
4,242 suggestions
Ty Olsson
as Pirate¹⁸ in Peter Pan 2025
Charlie Hunnam
as Pirate¹⁷ in Peter Pan 2025
Charlie Bewley
as Pirate¹⁶ in Peter Pan 2025
Michael Sheen
as Pirate¹⁵ in Peter Pan 2025
Gary Oldman
as Pirate¹⁴ in Peter Pan 2025
Billy Burke
as Pirate¹³ in Peter Pan 2025
Zeeko Zaki
as Pirate¹² in Peter Pan 2025
Christian Slater
as Pirate¹¹ in Peter Pan 2025
David Herman
as Pirate¹⁰ in Peter Pan 2025
Jamie Demetriou
as Pirate⁹ in Peter Pan 2025
Tim Blake Nelson
as Pirate⁸ in Peter Pan 2025
Josh Gad
as Pirate⁷ in Peter Pan 2025
Will Ferrell
as Pirate⁶ in Peter Pan 2025
Joel McHale
as Pirate⁵ in Peter Pan 2025
Jeff Goldblum
as Pirate⁴ in Peter Pan 2025
Chris Elliott
as Pirate³ in Peter Pan 2025
Jesse Spencer
as Pirate² in Peter Pan 2025
Kal Penn
as Pirate¹ in Peter Pan 2025
Domhnall Gleeson
as Pirate‹ in Peter Pan 2025
Lee Arenberg
as Pirate‘ in Peter Pan 2025