86,654 suggestions

Ryan Reynolds
as Kyle in Sleepaway Camp

FAKE
as Kyle in Sleepaway Camp

Kyle Gallner
as Kyle in Sleepaway Camp

Antony Starr
as Kyle in Sleepaway Camp
Jake Gyllenhaal
as Kyle in Sleepaway Camp

Zac Efron
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Aaron Taylor-Johnson
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

John Krasinski
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Nicolas Cage
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Nicholas Hoult
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Dylan O'Brien
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Chris Evans
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

James McAvoy
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Chris Pine
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Armie Hammer
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Jensen Ackles
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp
Jake Gyllenhaal
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Andrew Garfield
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Brad Pitt
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp

Robert Pattinson
as James Witherdale in Sleepaway Camp