Suggestions by @micahmadera
42,497 suggestions
Barret Oliver
as John Darling in Peter Pan (1983)
Jeff Cohen
as The Lost Boys in Peter Pan (1983)
Fred Savage
as Michael Darling in Peter Pan (1983)
Jennifer Connelly
as Wendy Darling in Peter Pan (1983)
Wallace Shawn
as Mr. Smee in Peter Pan (1983)
David Bowie
as Captain Hook in Peter Pan (1983)
River Phoenix
as Peter Pan in Peter Pan (1983)
Caitlin Carmichael
as Micahmadera in Actors/Actresses Who Should Play Love Interests to myCast Users
John Lithgow
as Professor Dumbledore in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)
Ty Simpkins
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural
Logan Lerman
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural
Robbie Amell
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural
Joe Keery
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural
Grant Gustin
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural
Lucas Till
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural
Mason Dye
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural
Jared Padalecki
as Han Solo (2010s) in Actors who could've play Han Solo in different decades
Miranda Otto
as Isolde in The Adventures of Merlin (Alternate Cast)
David Wenham
as Tristan in The Adventures of Merlin (Alternate Cast)
Gemma Arterton
as Nimueh in The Adventures of Merlin (Alternate Cast)