Suggestions by @micahmadera

Tom Schilling

as Caranthir in The Silmarillion

Ben Whishaw

as Maglor in The Silmarillion

Cillian Murphy

as Sauron in The Silmarillion

Liam Hemsworth

as Tuor in The Silmarillion

Henry Cavill

as Tuor in The Silmarillion

Daniel Radcliffe

as Albert Runcorn in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Emma Watson

as Mafalda Hopkirk in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Rupert Grint

as Reginald Cattermole in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Mark Hamill

as Kreacher in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Tanner Buchanan

as Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars: The Clone Wars live-action fancast

Jude Law

as Manwe in The Silmarillion

Chris Hemsworth

as Celegorm in The Silmarillion

Hugh Jackman

as Húrin Thalion in The Silmarillion

Carrie-Anne Moss

as Morwen in The Silmarillion

Sharlto Copley

as Barahir in The Silmarillion

Ioan Gruffudd

as Mablung in The Silmarillion

Megan Fox

as Elwing in The Silmarillion

Monica Bellucci

as Melian in The Silmarillion

Johann Urb

as Eärendil in The Silmarillion

Oscar Isaac

as Caranthir in The Silmarillion