Suggestions by @micahmadera

Michael Angarano

as Marty McFly (2005) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Anton Yelchin

as Marty McFly (2015) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Xolo Maridueña

as Marty McFly (2025) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Logan Lerman

as Marty McFly (2015) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Dylan O'Brien

as Marty McFly (2015) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Paul Walker

as Marty McFly (1995) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Marty McFly (1995) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Elijah Wood

as Marty McFly (1995) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Tobey Maguire

as Marty McFly (1995) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Jon Cryer

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Robert Downey Jr.

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Ralph Macchio

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

C. Thomas Howell

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Johnny Depp

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Ben Stiller

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

John Cusack

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Matthew Broderick

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Alex Winter

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Keanu Reeves

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years

Eric Stoltz

as Marty McFly (1985) in Actors who could play Marty McFly in different years