Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo
12,256 suggestions
Angela Bassett
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Kathy Bates
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Gabourey Sidibe
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Bella Thorne
as Actors and Actresses in spin off show in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Madison Iseman
as Actors and Actresses in spin off show in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Alicia Silverstone
as Actors and Actresses in spin off show in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Billie Lourd
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Naomi Grossman
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Leslie Grossman
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Frances Conroy
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Sarah Paulson
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Taissa Farmiga
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Emma Roberts
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Jessica Lange
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Kelsey Lea Jones
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Denis O'Hare
as Monty in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Billie Lourd
as Cassandra in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Frances Conroy
as Eve in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Yolanda in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Lily Rabe
as Samantha in American Horror Story Urban Legends