Suggestions by @maxhedroom

Harrison Ford

as Jake Lonergan, an amnesiac outlaw. in Cowboys & Aliens (1991)

Brian Dennehy

as Lancaster Dodd in The Master (1992)

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Freddie Quell in The Master (1992)

James Gandolfini

as Wizard in Taxi Driver (1996)

Kiefer Sutherland

as Sport in Taxi Driver (1996)

Fred Ward

as Wizard in Taxi Driver (1996)

James Coburn

as Charles Palantine in Taxi Driver (1996)

John Leguizamo

as Sport in Taxi Driver (1996)

Gwyneth Paltrow

as Betsy in Taxi Driver (1996)

Jon Favreau

as Tom in Taxi Driver (1996)

Woody Harrelson

as Sport in Taxi Driver (1996)

Philip Seymour Hoffman

as Tom in Taxi Driver (1996)

Oliver Platt

as Tom in Taxi Driver (1996)

Tom Sizemore

as Sport in Taxi Driver (1996)

Edward Norton

as Travis Bickle in Taxi Driver (1996)

Wilhelm von Homburg

as Eddie Dane in Miller's Crossing (1980)

Eric Roberts

as Bernie Bernbaum in Miller's Crossing (1980)

George C. Scott

as Leo O'Bannon in Miller's Crossing (1980)

Christopher Walken

as Tom Reagan in Miller's Crossing (1980)

Michael V. Gazzo

as Johnny Caspar in Miller's Crossing (1980)