Suggestions by @matthewchadd

Peter O'Toole

as Sherlock Holmes in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Alan Young

as Ebenezer Scrooge in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Kelsey Grammer

as Ebenezer Scrooge in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Duncan Regehr

as Count Dracula in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Tom Noonan

as Frankenstein's Monster in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Bert Lahr

as The Cowardly Lion in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Ray Bolger

as The Scarecrow in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Jack Haley

as The Tin Man in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Warren Clarke

as Quasimodo in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Sabu

as Mowgli in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Charlton Heston

as Moses in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Val Kilmer

as Moses in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Emilia Clarke

as Sarah Connor in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Jared Leto

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Joaquin Phoenix

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Heath Ledger

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Mark Hamill

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Jack Nicholson

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Cesar Romero

as The Joker in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Frank Langella

as Zorro in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters