Suggestions by @ masterofcool

Liv Tyler

as Sandra Williams in Blue Velvet (1996)

John Lithgow

as Franklin Booth in Blue Velvet (1996)

Edward Norton

as Jeffrey Beaumont in Blue Velvet (1996)

Ken Russell

as Director in Leon: The Professional (1984)

Michael Gough

as The Hotel Receptionist in Leon: The Professional (1984)

Tracey Walter

as Malky in Leon: The Professional (1984)

Talia Shire

as Mathilda's Mother in Leon: The Professional (1984)

Marcello Mastroianni

as Tony in Leon: The Professional (1984)

Dennis Hopper

as Norman Stansfield in Leon: The Professional (1984)

+1-1Score: 0

Winona Ryder

as Mathilda Lando in Leon: The Professional (1984)

+11-0Score: +11

Robert De Niro

as Leon in Leon: The Professional (1984)

+5-0Score: +5

Jeff Goldblum

as Patrick Bateman in American Psycho (1980)

+4-1Score: +3

Johnny Depp

as Patrick Bateman in American Psycho (1990)

+7-3Score: +4

Jonathan Brandis

as Cary McCarthy in Super 8 (1991)

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Joseph Lamb in Super 8 (1991)

James Earl Jones

as Cooper in Super 8 (1991)

Sidney Poitier

as Dr. Thomas Woodward in Super 8 (1991)

James Caan

as Colonel Richard Nelec in Super 8 (1991)

John Lithgow

as Deputy Jackson Lamb in Super 8 (1991)