Suggestions by @martinvoncramp86

Skeet Ulrich

as Deputy Hendricks in Jaws (1995)

Anne Heche

as Ellen Brody in Jaws (1995)

Kevin Bacon

as Matt Hooper in Jaws (1995)

Oliver Platt

as Sam Quint in Jaws (1995)

James Gandolfini

as Sam Quint in Jaws (1995)

Pierce Brosnan

as Sam Quint in Jaws (1995)

Treat Williams

as Chief Martin Brody in Jaws (1995)

Tom Berenger

as Chief Martin Brody in Jaws (1995)

Eric Roberts

as Chief Martin Brody in Jaws (1995)

James Woods

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws (1995)

Ron Silver

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws (1995)

Ray Winstone

as Requin in Tango and Cash (1997)

Jonathan Banks

as Owen in Tango and Cash (1997)

Alyssa Milano

as Katherine "Kiki" Tango in Tango and Cash (1997)

Donald Sutherland

as Yves Perret in Tango and Cash (1997)

Ron Silver

as Yves Perret in Tango and Cash (1997)

James Woods

as Yves Perret in Tango and Cash (1997)

J. T. Walsh

as Yves Perret in Tango and Cash (1997)

Nicolas Cage

as Lieutenant Gabriel "Gabe" Cash in Tango and Cash (1997)

Guy Pearce

as Lieutenant Raymond "Ray" Tango in Tango and Cash (1997)