Suggestions by @logantaperell

Robert Pattinson

as Laurent Thierry in Great Pretender

+2-1Score: +1

Lance Reddick

as Ultra Magnus in The Transformers

+4-5Score: -1

Peter Stormare

as Rudol Von Stroheim in Jojo's Bizarre Adventure

+0-4Score: -4

Paul Anderson

as Robert E.O. Speedwagon in Jojo's Bizarre Adventure

+4-4Score: 0

Tom Holkenborg

as Composer in Jojo's Bizarre Adventure

+3-0Score: +3

Matthew Vaughn

as Director in Jojo's Bizarre Adventure

+3-6Score: -3