Suggestions by @krmickey97
36,779 suggestions
Melissa Joan Hart
as Stephanie Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Anna Faris
as Stephanie Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Amy Smart
as Stephanie Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Brittany Daniel
as Stephanie Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Jamie-Lynn Sigler
as Polly Finch in American Pie (1999-2012)
Katharine Isabelle
as Polly Finch in American Pie (1999-2012)
Carly Pope
as Polly Finch in American Pie (1999-2012)
Christina Ricci
as Polly Finch in American Pie (1999-2012)
Marla Sokoloff
as Kaitlyn Meyers in American Pie (1999-2012)
Jordana Brewster
as Kaitlyn Meyers in American Pie (1999-2012)
Alexis Bledel
as Kaitlyn Meyers in American Pie (1999-2012)
Eliza Dushku
as Kaitlyn Meyers in American Pie (1999-2012)
Rachael Leigh Cook
as Jane Levenstein in American Pie (1999-2012)
Shiri Appleby
as Christa "Ozzy" Ostreicher in American Pie (1999-2012)
Katie Holmes
as Christa "Ozzy" Ostreicher in American Pie (1999-2012)
Marguerite Moreau
as Christa "Ozzy" Ostreicher in American Pie (1999-2012)
Jennifer Love Hewitt
as Christa "Ozzy" Ostreicher in American Pie (1999-2012)
Danielle Harris
as Jane Levenstein in American Pie (1999-2012)
Brittany Murphy
as Jane Levenstein in American Pie (1999-2012)
Melanie Lynskey
as Jane Levenstein in American Pie (1999-2012)