Suggestions by @krmickey97
36,669 suggestions
Emma Stone
as Mallory Pike in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Brenda Song
as Claudia Kishi in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Amber Tamblyn
as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Mary Elizabeth Winstead
as Mary Anne Spier in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Joe Keery
as Charlie Thomas in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jacob Elordi
as Charlie Thomas in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jodie Foster
as Dawn Schafer in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Nicholas Hamilton
as Logan Bruno in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jacob Bertrand
as Logan Bruno in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Ryan Gosling
as Logan Bruno in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Walker Scobell
as Logan Bruno in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Logan Bruno in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Camilla and Rebecca Rosso
as Mariah and Miranda Shillaber in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Kirsten Dunst
as Dawn Schafer in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jennifer Lawrence
as Dawn Schafer in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Victoria Justice
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Dafne Keen
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Olivia Rodrigo
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Reese Witherspoon
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Teagan Croft
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)